I watched two
seasons of Spartacus and I couldn’t bear to sit through a third. One question
comes to mind…Why do Americans almost always ruin ancient Greek or Roman
mythologies? Off the top of my head some of the big productions that sucked big
time were: Troy(They did not even bother to find a Helen that looked like
Helen, they found a German looking one instead!), Three Hundred (word to the
wise…when you shout every important thing people tend to tune you out!), Clash of the Titans and the list goes on and on. Seriously don’t touch
Greek mythology, you don’t get it so leave it alone!
Going back to the matter at hand: Spartacus
series versus Rome Series. Well really there is no comparison whatsoever but I
would like to hold a God-awful example against a good one.
The first time I tried to watch Spartacus I
left it after the 2nd episode. One of our friends insisted that it
gets better so I tried again. Alright..it did get better only to the point of
being watchable if you make an effort. The second season, which is like a
backround to the original story, was God-awful and from what I could see in the
third season (that is as far as I watched over my shoulder as I played my
online game while husband watched it on the couch) simply sullied the good name
of God-awful!
What bugged me?
Well to begin with, modern hair-cuts bugged
me! The women who wear the fashionable hair of 21st century in the
first season bugged me! Really? Seriously?
The yank looking Spartacus who replaced the
actor after he died of cancer bugged me! Yea all Thracians look like Private
Ryan for sure!
 | |
| Thats the yank |
The pornography bugged me! I am not against
nudity or pornography in series or movies for as long as it is not there
because the production seriously lacks insights and so they have to make money
through horny teenager audience. Oh they have to throw in homosexuality too! Of
course since they are going for the commerce there has to be something in it
for everyone right? Oh and lets not rule out girl on girl...thats big money
too!! Get some perspective geniuses!
The slow motion- marinara-sauced-
screaming-as-if-your-nuts-are-being-squeezed-fight-scenes bugged me!!! Alright
it became a hit with Three Hundred (actually I call it Baywatch in ancient times!)
but do you have to use it in EVERY frigging fight scene? All I can hear is:
-Rooooaaaaaaarrrrrr!!!
-Grrrrraaaaaaaaaawwwwwlllllll!!!
-Aaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhh!!!!
Ouuuffff just DIE already!
The Amazons coming out of nowhere bugged
me! The slave women all of a sudden becoming elven archers after like training
twice...yea that sounds real. If women are so much better than men in fighting
and are so easily trainable then why the hell have we been sending men off to
war???? Train a couple of housewives and you will get the best platoon or so it
is conveyed in the series. And this comes from a woman!
Now that I am done, rightly trashing the
Spartacus series, lets take a look at a Good example. HBO’s Rome. I am not
going to get into the costumes and sets because although they do create the atmosphere
you need it is not necessarily essential in a good production for as long as
there is merit in the work. Example? BBC’s “I Claudius”. Costumes and decorations
are old fashioned but the role acting, staying true to the scenario, Herculic
work on part of the director make up for it and after like 30 years the
production is still good as a theatrical work on television for those who know
a little bit of history.
So what is it about Rome? Did it not have
pornography? Did it not have elements that should not have been there? Did it
not have commercial fear? Did it not have amazons? Did it not portary Livia with only one son, ruling out Drusus hence ruling out the fourth Ceasar Claudius? Did it not change history according to its wishes? At some points yes. It did
but it still was one hell of a production because damn it the actors knew how
to act, the director knew how not to base his work on cheap tricks but rather
use them to increase his audience and the story was as true to the reality as
it gets when talking about the directors’ and scenarists’ obsession to tweak
the story lines (and even history) because it aint good enough and they know
better (please note my sarcastic tone here!!) 
But I watched Rome and I liked it. And then
I watched it again and I liked it again. Because it was good work! It was a
good story (history actually) with some important-to-the-story- pornography
here and there. It lacked fight and battle scenes; I admit that. But hey that
did not bother me one bit. The ones that were there satisfied me well enough.
What did Spartacus have? Some story thrown
here and there between really tasteless and stupid pornography (FYI if I want
to watch pornography I can find tons on the internet!) and fight scenes.
Rome is how it is done. Commercialism and a
good work perfectly intertwined.
Spartacus is how it should not be done!
And Now I am done!
Well, you just shoudnt't even try to compare these two series. (And I don't even mentioning 'I Claudius'). Why? Because in one side you have a well structed expensive historical series, and in the other side you have something very very cheap. And I don't mean cheap as cost only. Because Spartakus is cheap in everything. Is like watching Zeena in ancient Roman times.
ReplyDeleteAs for the tricks they use? Again cheap. As you mentioned, in every episode they MUST put at minimum 3 sex scenes, and in EVERY but EVERY fight, half of the scenes are in slow motion, and half of the times the camera fills with ketchup! eee sorry, Blood I mean!:P
And you made a mistake. When we tried to watch it at first, we watched HALF episode and closed it. About 2 weeks later we made it through the whole first episode, and one week later we tried to see the second one. Yeah! It was THAT good! :P
Truth is, that after these 2 episodes it gets better. But that's only for the first season. The rest... not even worth mentioning!
It is really pitty that these cheap series are continuing on and on, whilst series like Rome stops after 2 seasons. Really pitty...
Rofl I cracked up :)))
DeleteRome = historical series
Spartacus = Sextorical Series :P
By the way I dont think that was ketchup dear...I think that was Marinara Sauce from the closest restaurant to the set *sinister giggle*
ok, quite a critical report here and as I have not watched any great length of either series I could not comment on them, but I do have to ask a question....Nova, if Spartacus was really that bad....why on earth did you watch all of it up to season 3?? This is the main reason that these kind of shows are made and go on to be made for 3/4 seasons, cause people end up watching them, no matter how poor they are....something about them keeps you coming back for more....I mean think about it...you called it "cheap in everything", "like watching Zena in Roman times" and yet you still watched it....LOL!!! in other words, the creators did what they intended...they made a cheap show with cheap action shots slowed down to extend the scenes, using cheap Marinara sauce from the local restuarant....but no matter...cause guess what...you watched it anyway :))))
ReplyDeleteSorry buddy, I don't mean to make fun, as I said, I have not seen either series enough to pass comment, but based on your agreement of Tinny's comments and the addition of your own opinion of Spartacus, it does beg the question, why watch it?? At least Tinny had the sense to stop..... :)))